Why Fagioli Could Return to Juventus: Fiorentina’s Doubts and a Complicated Buyout Clause

Nicolò Fagioli’s future remains uncertain as Fiorentina weighs whether to make his loan move from Juventus permanent. IlBianconero report that the midfielder, who joined Fiorentina in February on a paid loan with a conditional obligation to buy, initially impressed with strong performances. However, his form dipped in recent months, partly due to increased media scrutiny following revelations about his involvement in a betting scandal.

The Details of the Deal

Fagioli’s transfer to Fiorentina was structured as a loan for €2.5 million, with an obligation to buy for €13.5 million plus €2.5 million in bonuses if Fiorentina qualify for European competition next season. Juventus would also receive 10% of any future resale. If Fiorentina fails to secure European football, the obligation turns into an option, giving the club the right—but not the requirement—to complete the purchase.

A Complicated Scenario

Fiorentina’s chances of qualifying for Europe now hang by a thread. To do so, they must win their final match against Udinese and hope Lazio loses at home to Lecce. If this scenario does not play out, the buyout clause becomes optional, and Fiorentina will have to decide whether to invest over €13 million in Fagioli despite his recent struggles.

Fiorentina’s Doubts

While Fagioli was brought in at the specific request of coach Raffaele Palladino and initially justified the investment, his emotional and performance decline after March has raised concerns. The club is now carefully considering whether to proceed with the purchase, especially given the significant financial commitment involved.

Juventus’ Perspective

Juventus, on the other hand, are open to Fagioli’s return. With the possible departure of Douglas Luiz in the summer and the need to strengthen the squad for the upcoming Club World Cup, Fagioli could fill an important gap in midfield. His return would be especially timely if Fiorentina decides not to exercise the buyout option.

What Happens Next

Everything hinges on Fiorentina’s final league result and their subsequent decision. If they qualify for Europe, the buyout becomes mandatory and Fagioli will remain in Florence. If not, Juventus may welcome back a player who, despite recent challenges, still holds significant potential and value for the club’s future plans.

Alex Hubner

Alex Hubner

Juventus fan and journalist.

Don't Miss